Indeed, the first one was on the whole positive. I particularly enjoyed the Shire & Rivendell settings. Most of the changes (Glorfindel-Arwen; Bombadil; moving Boromir's death) made at least some sense.
But the cinema version of TTT was simply awful. Faramir was one of my favourites and I couldn't forgive that. And the warg fight/horse kissing -- don't get me onto that.
And, oh god, RotK -- suffice to say, Denethor was another of my favourites.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
branchandroot
(no subject)
Date: 2014-10-08 05:51 pm (UTC)But the cinema version of TTT was simply awful. Faramir was one of my favourites and I couldn't forgive that. And the warg fight/horse kissing -- don't get me onto that.
And, oh god, RotK -- suffice to say, Denethor was another of my favourites.